IT-Analysis.com
IT-Analysis.com Logo
Enterprise SME Business Issues Technology Services Channels
Module Header
David TebbuttTeblog
David Tebbutt
19th November - Collaboration: the old way. Why not?
Martin BanksBanks Statement
Martin Banks
18th November - This Cloud has a silver lining
Peter AbrahamsAbrahams Accessibility
Peter Abrahams
18th November - Major new accessibility features in Firefox 3.0.4
Martin BanksBanks Statement
Martin Banks
17th November - Psychology of data ownership may be changing at last
Tony LockFreeform Comment
Tony Lock
16th November - Clouds yet to fill the IT skies
Module Header
Q. How many email addresses do you have?
 
  • addtomyyahoo4
  • Subscribe in NewsGator Online
  • Add to My AOL
  • Subscribe with Bloglines
  • Add to netvibes
  • Add to Google
Blogs > Robin Bloor
Microsoft and the Mac - Sleepless in Seattle; YouOS; HP and Mercury; AVID: Close But No Cigar
Robin Bloor By: Robin Bloor
Published: 1st August 2006
Copyright © 2006

Microsoft and the Mac—Sleepless in Seattle

Microsoft (hereinafter referred to as Little Blue) is clearly aware that Apple is now a threat to its hegemony. Stave Ballmer must have stopped at Starbucks and noticed the number of Apple laptops in use. (Apple's share of the US laptop market has doubled to 12% in a year). Or maybe he's been watching the “I'm a PC and I'm a Mac” ads that are running on US TV.

So here's what Little Blue is doing:

  1. Vista imitates some of the “cool” interface features of OS X. (The problem here for Little Blue is that it doesn't know the features of OS X that it will actually have to compete with. It will find out in August, which is too late for Vista).
  2. Little Blue is going to launch its own version of the iPod in November. Remember that Little Blue has been taking evening courses in device design in order to deliver an XBox with teen appeal. The iPod-wannabe will be called Zune (to rhyme with iTune) and will not suffer from Neanderthal design influences. (Little Blue's problem here is that iPod users have invested their music collections—bought, uploaded and stolen—in Apple's proprietary file formats. People really value their gigabytes of stolen music. Why change?)
  3. Little Blue is urging PC manufacturers to, er, design PCs differently (according to Business Week). Here's what it is recommending; colours—black and translucent white, PC cases with “accelerated curves”. Astonishingly original. (Little Blue's problem here is that these design ideas are not astonishingly original).

Little Blue has spent too long imitating the now defunct IBM strategy; wait for someone else to validate the market and then move in to take it. Nowadays the first mover has greater momentum. You cannot necessarily close the gap with dollars and FUD.

Little Blue needs to do what Big Blue did; drop the monopolistic approach and get a new business model. That was how IBM pulled off its Phoenix-from-the-flames act.

In August, at the Apple developer's conference, Steve Jobs will make some announcements. There are two things he will announce for sure:

  1. A new top of the range Intel Apple to replace the current G5.
  2. OS X, Leopard. This will try to be a Vista-killer, aimed at making Vista look like yesterday's OS

He may also announce a new iPod, because one is due. It would keep the financial analysts happy. There's a rumour, probably true, that Apple will also announce a video rental service (based on movie download with attached DRM) in concert with an iPod announcement.

The key announcement ought to be Leopard. That's where Apple has its biggest opportunity.

Note 1: I've been suggesting since January that Apple will support virtualization and thus Leopard will probably run “Windows in a box”. Recent news that Apple stores will sell the Parallels virtualization product through its Apple stores suggests that I'm wrong. Parallels has that market to itself for the moment.

Note 2: The last call that the Panther version of OS X makes as it closes down is die_you_gravy_sucking_pigdog() (from BSD's shutdown.c module). That's no way to talk to an iMac.

YouOS

Ever fancied having an OS within a browser, so that there was a desktop waiting for you in every cybercafe or airport lounge in the world? If so, go to www.youos.com and grab yourself a free account. If you can't be bothered to do that, just imagine a web page with a wallpaper background and a few icons you can click on, plus a drop down menu at the top left for icon haters.

Does this idea have legs? I'm not sure. It depends on how it evolves. It would be a good deal more impressive than it currently is, if it ran as the browser itself, rather than from within a window in the browser. The YouOS desktop has a (primitive) browser of its own and if you want to access www.writely.com you can put that url in the browser-within-a-browser and, at your request, it will open up a new tab in FireFox that displays Writely.com. That's fine, but it feels wrong.

The idea doesn't have legs.

HP and Mercury

Credible rumours that HP had Mercurial intentions turned out to be true. The Mercury acquisition is good for HP for 3 reasons:

  1. The software portfolios are complementary.
  2. The combined revenue (about $2 billion) turns HP into a serious system management/infrastructure software player (if there was any doubt—and I never had any).
  3. HP now has a SOA registry and other additional SOA assets.

Reader Comments

We are no longer accepting comments against this item. We suggest contacting the author directly.

1st August 2006: 'Graham' said:

YouOS has been done before. It was in the 90s and it was called WebOS. Great idea but dreadful implementation. You could go out to lunch between responses. What's the likelihood of this being any better? Writely has the "write" idea. Keep it simple.

Reply to Graham?

1st August 2006: 'Robin' said:

"users have invested their music collections—bought, uploaded and stolen—in Apple's proprietary file formats." AAC is not Apple's file format. The iPod is supporting AAC, MP3, MP3 VBR, Audible, Apple Lossless, WAV and AIFF. Only the AAC songs protected with FairPlay DRM and downloaded from the iTunes Music Store are proprietary. On February 23, 2006 Apple announced that the iTunes Music Store had sold 1 billion songs. Apple has sold 59 million iPods so far. That's less than 20 protected songs per iPod. They will reach 2 billion songs soon enough, the number of protected songs sold for each iPod will be about 34 (or less because more iPods will be sold in the coming weeks/months).

Reply to Robin?

1st August 2006: 'Myles' said:

Leopard won't be a "Vista-killer". Leopard will be a Tiger-killer.

Reply to Myles?

1st August 2006: 'Tonio Loewald' said:

I think YouOS / WebOS etc. are good ideas BUT they need to take into account the fact that they're in a web browser and leverage that rather than pretend to be a two-bit OS. E.g. assume that any complex development will be done via other web dev tools and work towards easing integration of those tools. In other words, concentrate on being GLUE.

Reply to Tonio Loewald?

9th August 2006: 'Sarah Galletly' said:

I think in terms of the eternal Microsoft/Apple struggle that the outcome will largely be down to time. At the moment the main computer/software purchasing market are made up of generations who were brought up (either through school or at home) on Microsoft. And we all know how stubborn people can be with straying from an OS after they've become so familiarised with it.

Therefore I think the real surge in the Apple market will come when the current/next generation reach purchasing age, because as more and more kids are being brought up on Macs, Windows may slowly become the "foreign" and Apple the "standard." But who knows? Time will tell no doubt.

(And just in case you've forgotten me, I'm the English student you sat next to at the Bloor annual dinner last year and talked about Shakespeare with for several hours.)

Reply to Sarah Galletly?

Advertisement



Published by: IT Analysis Communications Ltd.
T: +44 (0)203 051 5760 | F: +44 (0)870 345 9922
Email: